Myanmar's awful choice

23 April 2008

Apr 23rd 2008
[Source - Economist.com]

A referendum its people cannot win

IN EMBASSIES abroad, voting has already begun in the referendum on Myanmar’s new constitution, which will be held in-country on May 10th. The ruling junta advertises it as an important step forward on its “roadmap” to democratic, civilian rule. If only.

Rather the referendum is, in the words of Paulo Sergio Pinheiro, the United Nations’ special rapporteur on human rights in Myanmar, a “ritual without real content”.

Or perhaps it is even worse than that: a ritual with content, symbolising and confirming the sheer misery of Myanmar’s plight and threatening to make it permanent. A junta-appointed committee took 15 years to draft the constitution, which offers nothing close to democracy.

It gives the army chief the power to intervene in politics at will. Several cabinet seats would be reserved for army officers, as would 25% of seats in both houses of parliament.

A bizarre clause is apparently tailor-made to bar Aung San Suu Kyi, the detained opposition leader, from elected office. When Myanmar last held elections, she was banned because of her foreign connections: she was married to a foreigner and had spent much of her life abroad.

Her husband has since died, and she has been in Myanmar without interruption—mostly under lock and key. Now, however, those whose “children or their spouses” are foreign are excluded. Miss Suu Kyi’s two sons are British, having been deprived of their Burmese citizenship.

Despite all this, some of the regime’s critics used to think the constitution worth voting for: it is, after all, the only chance of change that is on offer. And it does envisage some sort of political process, with a parliament, which implies debate and even, perhaps, disagreement.

To be blithely optimistic, this process might gather a momentum of its own. It might, for example, expose the undoubted rifts within the junta.

And, by bringing in the “ceasefire groups”—representatives of ethnic insurgencies that are at present quiescent—it would bring a formal end to some of the world’s longest-running armed conflicts.

Now, however, it is hard to find anyone outside the junta itself who favours a “yes” vote. There are two main reasons for this. The first is the junta’s brutal suppression of last autumn’s monk-led protests. A much feared and loathed regime proved itself even more hateful.

Second is the strengthening of provisions in the draft designed to make it hard to change it in future. Amendment will require at least 75% of the votes in parliament—ie, including those of some of the soldiers—and 50% of eligible voters in a subsequent referendum.

So the constitution seems a way of entrenching eternal military domination.

Any hint of a campaign for a “no” vote in Myanmar has been suppressed—those caught scrawling graffiti face long jail sentences; T-shirts bearing the word “Nobody”, which were made in Thailand and which Burmese had taken to wearing in discreet protest, are being removed from shop shelves.

With no independent poll-monitors, even if there is a “no” vote, we might never know. The generals will surely remember the embarrassment of being thrashed in the election they held in 1990.

So the looming vote evokes in some activists not the hope of change, however imperfect, but desperation over its impossibility. In that sense, it is comparable to the role of the Beijing Olympics in Tibet—almost a last chance to make a futile protest heard.

In a rare (if minor) incident of terrorism in Myanmar, two small bombs exploded in the centre of Yangon on Sunday April 20th. The government has blamed a group of exiled dissidents. But the one thing Myanmar is not short of is angry, desperate people.

1 comments:

e8c6h9z7t6 said...


免費a片aa片免費看網友一夜情聊天室網愛俱樂部激情網愛kk視訊sogo 成人論壇成人動畫論壇免費情色影片觀賞免費貼圖區日本美女寫真集av女優VS檳榔西施ut聊天室聊天室色情豆豆聊天室色情聊天室男人尋夢園聊天室080中部人聊天室123上班族聊天室 sm聊天室愛情公寓聊天室一夜情聊天室苗栗人聊天室激情成人網愛聊天室激情網愛聊天哈啦聊天室影音視訊聊天室原住民聊天室情色網重車論壇av女優日本大奶女優av女優線上觀賞av女優無碼影城av女優電影av女優圖貼女優做愛撿來的av女優av女優排行日本av女優免費影片區av女優神藤美香人氣女優日本女優美女寫真免費欣賞av女優無碼a片女優無碼日本女優嘟嘟情色網台灣女優無碼女優女優網歐美女優女優探索網女優王國sex女優王國av女優介紹女優寫真無碼av女優日本av女優影片百分百成人圖線上交友網成人愛情交易所免費視訊美女網夜激情成人聊天室小潘潘成人無碼片小弟弟成人娛樂臺灣18歲成人網路視訊聊天即時視訊聊天一對多視訊聊天免費真人視訊辣妹免費下載成人短片☆♀ 18成人 ☆♀夜未眠成人影城美眉影音視訊聊天室080心悸動聊天室已婚上班族聊天室上班族偷情聊天室網友情聊天室免費辣妹視訊聊天網美女視訊聊天室視訊錄影成人視訊交友聊天即時通成人視訊本土辣妹視訊大奶美女視訊即時通視訊 限制級電影辣妹視訊聊天網線上視訊聊天網18禁成人影音情色影片下載限制級影片自拍美女短片免費看情色電影院限制級a片免費觀看視訊辣妹脫衣秀